What will this cost me?
Every property is different. Answer four quick questions for a planning estimate of how a completed transition could change your yearly costs. Want to check the math? Every figure is traced in Sources and Methodology at the bottom of this page.
How this calculator relates to the Long Range Plan
It shows the end result, not the path. The calculator compares today with a completed transition. The changes would arrive in phases from 2027 on, and the "When each change arrives" table in your results shows how. See the assessment diagram.
City property tax: 4 mills today, 5 assumed. The City levies 4 mills now.3,4,5 The Long Range Plan's projections assume 5. That is an assumption, not an adopted rate, so the calculator counts only the one extra mill as new. The City Council sets the rate each year.
The two fees are preliminary planning estimates. They are not adopted charges. Which properties would pay them, and how they would be billed, will depend on the City's adopted ordinance; see how these fees are calculated and collected. The calculator applies neither fee to vacant lots. The Public Safety fee ($632 or $888 a year) is from the July 2026 study. The Long Range Plan gives $600 to $672 a year for the sheriff option4,2 and no figure for a police department. The Recreation fee ($187.85) is from the May 2026 study; the plan says that fee will be set in 2029.4
The 2.5% sales tax is not in effect. It is not in effect in Holiday Island; it is a potential future ballot initiative. The calculator includes it as if voters approve it.
The full detail is in Sources and Methodology.
Your estimated household impact
This is the change a completed transition would make, not your whole tax bill. Taxes you already pay that aren't changing are left out.
What's included and what isn't
Included: the HISID assessment going away, and the new City charges: the two service fees, one additional mill of property tax, and the 2.5% sales tax (not in effect in Holiday Island; a potential future ballot initiative).
Left out because they don't change: county, school and other existing property tax; the City's existing 4 mills; the 1.5-mill road allocation the City receives from the county road tax; and the state and county sales tax.
Not modeled: the homestead credit and any other individual credits or adjustments.
For your combined tax picture at current rates, see the Tax Comparison page.
| Item | Annual amount | Source |
|---|
When each change arrives
The Long Range Plan moves services in phases, so the change does not land in a single year. Dates after 2027 are the plan's targets, and each step depends on the petition or budget noted.
| When | What changes on your bills | Amount |
|---|
Phases and the $54.25 sewer-loan reduction are from the Long Range Plan, September 22, 2026. The plan does not state the other assessment reductions; they will be set in HISID's budgets. Fee amounts are preliminary planning estimates from the earlier feasibility studies, not adopted charges; actual applicability and billing will depend on the City's adopted ordinance. The City's January 2026 State of the City said the sales tax would be effective in 2027; that is conditional on voter approval, applicable legal requirements and the actual implementation schedule.
Putting the number in context
What it pays for
Sheriff or police coverage, the fire department, about 69 miles of roads, and the golf courses, marina, pools and trails. The costs are not new; the way they are paid for is.
Standing still is not free
Today's bill reflects today's structure, not the permanent cost of doing nothing. The Long Range Plan projects that HISID's current assessment capacity could be exhausted around 2037 under its assumptions, and roads, public safety and recreation need funding under any structure.
Why this matters →Shared with visitors
The sales tax is the one piece paid by everyone who spends money here, not only by property owners. Your own share depends on how much you buy locally.
In line with the neighbors
In this site's comparison, a fully transitioned Holiday Island lands within about $430 a year of Berryville, Green Forest and Eureka Springs in property and sales tax on the same illustrative household. That comparison leaves out service fees, which this calculator includes.
See the comparison →How was this calculated?
A note for residents on a fixed income
If you're retired, on Social Security, or managing a fixed monthly budget, "new tax" understandably sounds like unwelcome news no matter how the rest of this site frames it. That reaction deserves a straight answer, not a sales pitch.
What "ad valorem" means — and why it changes who pays what
Ad valorem is Latin for "according to value." It's the standard term for a tax calculated as a percentage of what something is worth, rather than a flat dollar amount charged to everyone alike. City property tax, modeled here at the 5-mill planning assumption, is an ad valorem tax: every property is taxed at the same rate — 0.1% of its estimated market value — so the dollar amount scales with what the property is actually worth. HISID's current assessment works the opposite way: it's a flat, per-property charge that doesn't look at value at all, so a modest home and a much larger one on the lake pay the identical dollar amount today.
| Charge | $150,000 home | $850,000 lakefront home |
|---|---|---|
| Today's flat HISID assessment | $834.60 | $834.60 |
| ...as a share of the home's value | 0.56% | 0.10% |
| City ad valorem property tax at 5 mills (planning assumption) | $150.00 | $850.00 |
| ...as a share of the home's value | 0.10% | 0.10% |
Today, both homes pay the exact same $834.60 HISID assessment — which means, measured against what each home is worth, the $150,000 home is paying more than five times the effective rate of the $850,000 home. Under an ad valorem property tax, both properties pay the same 0.1% rate: the lakefront home pays more in dollars, as you'd expect from a property worth over five times as much, but the two homes carry the same proportional burden. This fairness argument is about how the property-tax component is distributed, not about whether your total bill goes up or down overall — use the calculator above for your own full picture.
The flat assessment you pay today has no relief built in. Real property tax does.
HISID's current assessment is a flat charge — everyone in a given category pays the same amount, with no discount for income or age. Arkansas's homestead tax credit and constitutional property-tax protections apply to the standard annual property tax billed on assessed value, not to a special-district assessment like HISID's. They already apply to eligible Holiday Island homeowners under the existing property-tax system, and they continue to apply as the City's tax structure evolves. The proposed additional city millage does not create a new homestead credit or a new eligibility category. Here is what those protections are:
The Homestead Tax Credit
Arkansas gives eligible homeowners a credit on the property tax for their primary residence.
Arkansas increased the homestead property-tax credit from $600 to $675 beginning with the 2026 assessment year. As a result, property-tax receipts from earlier years may show the previous $600 credit.
The credit lowers what you owe; it doesn't change the millage rate. You don't get an extra credit because a city millage is added.
This calculator does not subtract the homestead credit. Check your current amount with the Carroll County Assessor.
Source: Arkansas DFA — Property Tax Relief Programs; Act 174 of 2026 (HB1103).
The 65+ / disabled assessment freeze
Under Arkansas Amendment 79, homeowners who qualify for the homestead tax credit and who are age 65 or older, or disabled, may be eligible to have the taxable assessed value of their homestead frozen.
The freeze is not automatic. Eligible homeowners must apply with the county assessor's office.
A frozen assessed value may still increase if there is new construction or a substantial improvement to the property. A buyer does not inherit the previous owner's limitation.
The freeze applies to assessed value, not to the tax bill. Millage rates, Urban Service District fees, and other charges can still change, so it does not guarantee that your total bill stays flat.
Source: Arkansas Assessment Coordination Division — Property Tax Relief. Confirm eligibility and how to apply with the Carroll County Assessor.
The 5% annual assessment growth limitation
Arkansas Amendment 79 limits how fast a property's assessed value can rise because of a countywide reappraisal.
For a qualifying homestead used as a primary residence, the limit is generally 5% a year. For other property, including vacant lots, it is generally 10% a year. Both apply until the property reaches its full assessed value.
New construction, substantial improvements and newly discovered property are treated differently.
This limits growth in assessed value. It does not cap your total tax bill, which also depends on millage rates and fees.
Source: Arkansas Assessment Coordination Division — Property Tax Relief (Amendment 79).
The one part of this bill that flexes with you
Unlike a flat assessment or a fixed fee, the proposed 2.5% sales tax would only apply to what you actually spend — a lighter spending year means a smaller amount of this specific cost, the same way it would with any sales tax. A flat fee does not vary in that way. Revenue from a local sales tax may support municipal services and infrastructure; how much it raises depends on taxable spending in the city by residents and visitors.
Why the recreation fee would apply whether or not you use the amenities
Not everyone golfs, boats, or swims — and it's a fair question why a property owner would pay the proposed Recreation Urban Service District fee regardless. The reasoning usually given is that community amenities can affect a community's appeal as a whole, not only the people who use them. The points below summarize that reasoning and its limits.
They can support your home's value
Research suggests that parks, recreational facilities, golf courses, marinas, and other community amenities can contribute to neighborhood desirability and quality of life. The actual effect on property values varies by location, property characteristics, market conditions, and the quality and accessibility of the amenities.
For Holiday Island, the golf courses, marina, pools, trails, and other recreational facilities are part of what distinguishes the community from other residential areas.
These amenities do not guarantee a particular increase in property value, but maintaining them may help preserve the community's appeal to current and future homeowners.
They're part of what attracts people to a community
According to the National Recreation and Park Association, 90% of U.S. adults consider parks and recreation an important local government service. That is a public-opinion finding about local government services, not a statistic about home buying or property values.
Holiday Island's lake access, golf courses, marina, pools and trails help distinguish it from surrounding communities. Maintaining them may contribute to the community's long-term attractiveness to new residents and visitors.
Letting them decline could have broader economic consequences
Holiday Island's recreation facilities are part of the community's identity. Allowing recreational amenities to deteriorate could have broader economic consequences, including reduced community desirability, deferred maintenance costs, and potential effects on surrounding property values.
The actual impact would depend on what happens to the facilities and surrounding properties. Maintaining them may help preserve the community's appeal, but it does not guarantee that property values will rise.
Source: National Recreation and Park Association, "Parks and Recreation Is Essential" (public opinion on parks and recreation as a local government service).
None of that erases the honest fact that the Recreation and Public Safety fees, as currently estimated, are flat charges with no income-based discount — that's still true, and worth saying plainly rather than glossing over. But "I don't use it" and "it doesn't benefit me" aren't quite the same thing here.
None of this changes the honest bottom line either: for most improved properties, this transition is a net cost increase, not a decrease. Use the calculator above with your own numbers to see your real one, not a hypothetical. But it's not an increase without guardrails — and if it turns out to be more than the community is willing to accept, the built-in off-ramps — the two Urban Service District petitions — exist specifically so residents can say so.
Sources and Methodology
This section is for readers who want to check the math. It gives the formula and source behind every line, and the legal background. You don't need it to use the calculator.
How the six line items are calculated
The calculator adds together six line items using the source study's flat fees, with two adjustments: the study counted a full 5-mill city property tax as new, and this calculator counts only the one mill above the 4 the City already levies; and the study charged vacant lots the Recreation fee, which this calculator does not. Your net annual change is simply the sum of these six numbers. The Public Safety fees are the July 2026 (Session 2) estimates; the published examples further down let you cross-check against the original May 2026 presentation.
| Line item | How it's calculated | Source |
|---|---|---|
| HISID assessment goes away | A flat amount is subtracted: −$834.60/year for an improved (developed) property, or −$513.60/year for a vacant lot — the current HISID assessment for each category. This is the assumed completed-transition scenario: the full reduction arrives only after every phase is done, so it is not an immediate saving, and its timing depends on the transition process and the approvals it requires.1 | Current charge (ending) |
| Recreation Urban Service District fee | A flat +$187.85/year for an improved property, regardless of property value, and $0 for a vacant lot. The May 2026 study also applied this fee to vacant lots; the calculator leaves it off because how vacant lots would be treated depends on the City's adopted fee methodology. Revenue generated by recreational amenities, including the golf courses and marina, may help offset operating costs and could potentially reduce the amount needed from the property-owner fee. The $187.85 amount is a preliminary planning estimate from the May 2026 feasibility study, which already counted on amenity revenue; it is not an adopted City charge. The final fee is to be set in 2029 and will depend on the approved district budget and available revenue. More on recreation revenue.1 | Early estimate (set in 2029) |
| Public Safety Urban Service District fee | A flat fee charged only to improved properties: +$632/year if the city keeps the sheriff/deputy contract, or +$888/year if it forms its own police department — whichever option you select. Vacant lots are shown at $0, as in the study's model. Both amounts are July 2026 feasibility-study estimates, not adopted City charges, and the district would be formed only by petition.1 | Proposed (study figure) |
| City property tax, one additional mill (real estate) | Market-value method: your entered market value × 20% × 0.001 (the same as × 0.0002). Arkansas assesses real property at 20% of its value, and one mill is 0.1% of assessed value. Taxable-value method: your entered taxable assessed value × 0.001, with no further ratio applied. The City already levies 4 mills; the Long Range Plan's planning assumption is 5, so only the fifth mill is counted as new. Five mills is an assumption, not an adopted rate.2 | Planning assumption (4 to 5 mills) |
| City property tax, one additional mill (personal property) | Your entered assessed personal property value × 0.001. One mill is 0.1% of assessed value, and the figure on your county statement is already the assessed value (20% of market value), so no further ratio is applied. This only applies to improved (occupied) properties, since the source model doesn't attribute household vehicles to vacant lots.2 | Planning assumption (4 to 5 mills) |
| Estimated household impact of proposed 2.5% sales tax | By default, a flat modeled estimate of +$270/year for an improved property, from the feasibility study's household spending assumptions, and $0 for a vacant lot. That is $10,800 of assumed annual taxable spending × the proposed 2.5% rate; it is a modeling assumption, not a measured household average. If you enter your own annual taxable spending, the calculator uses that amount × 2.5% instead. Actual cost depends on what you buy and where each purchase is sourced.1 | Modeled estimate |
Two things worth calling out: the property-value fields only ever affect the two mill-rate lines — they don't change the flat fees — and for vacant lots both Urban Service District fee lines are $0, as is the "sales tax" line unless you enter your own spending.
- The flat dollar figures — the HISID assessment removed, the Recreation and Public Safety Urban Service District fees, and the sales-tax estimate — come directly from the Mayor's feasibility study presentations: "Can the City Do It All?" (May 2, 2026, revised May 6) and "The Future Holiday Island — Session 2: Protecting Our Citizens" (July 11, 2026, revised July 13). This calculator uses the more recent July figures throughout; see the Sources page for full citations. ↩ back to table
- The 20% assessment ratio and the 5-mill municipal property tax rate aren't figures unique to the feasibility study — they're general features of Arkansas law: Ark. Code Ann. § 26-26-303(c) sets the 20%-of-market-value assessment ratio, and the Arkansas Constitution, Article 12, § 4 limits the tax a city may levy on real and personal property to 5 mills in one year. That limit concerns the City's own general levy; county, school district and other levies are separate and are not limited by it. The City's adopted rate is 4 mills, and the 5-mill figure used here is the Long Range Plan's assumption. The How We'd Pay page covers how the study applies this same toolkit. ↩ back to table
Adopted rates, plan assumptions and legal notes
- What is adopted and what is not. The City's four-mill levy for 2026 collections is adopted. The five-mill figure is a Long Range Plan assumption; future millage depends on annual City Council decisions and applicable legal requirements. The Recreation and Public Safety fees are preliminary proposed amounts. Nothing shown as a new charge has been adopted.
- The five-mill limit. Five mills is the limit the Arkansas Constitution (Article 12, § 4) places on a city's own general property-tax levy.6 It applies to the municipal levy only. County, school district and other taxing jurisdictions levy their own millage, so the total millage on a property-tax bill is much higher than five mills.
- Amendment 79. With the market-value method, the estimate uses the standard 20% assessment ratio and does not model Amendment 79 assessment limitations for your property. With the taxable-value method, it uses the taxable assessed value you enter and applies no further ratio.
- Credits. The result is an estimate before the homestead credit and any other individual credits or tax adjustments.
- Personal property. The estimate uses one additional mill as a planning assumption. Actual personal property millage may be subject to applicable Arkansas statutory adjustments (see Ark. Code Ann. § 26-26-405) and should not be read as a guaranteed future rate.
- Road allocation. The separate 1.5-mill road allocation that goes to the City from the county road tax is part of the existing bill and is not expected to change, so it is not counted.
- Sales tax. The feasibility study states the $270 household estimate; the $10,800 of taxable spending is this site's arithmetic from it ($270 ÷ 2.5%). Both are modeling assumptions. The tax is not in effect in Holiday Island; it is a potential future ballot initiative. If voters approve it, when it takes effect depends on applicable legal requirements and the actual implementation schedule.
- Earlier versions. The feasibility study, and earlier versions of this page, counted all five mills as new.
Market value, assessed value, and taxable value — three different numbers
Arkansas county assessors track three distinct figures for every property. Knowing which one is which matters for this calculator — and for reading your own assessment notice.
Market value
What the county estimates the property is worth. This is the number this calculator asks for by default.
Full assessed value
Generally 20% of market value for Arkansas real property. Do not enter this figure for your home — the calculator already applies the 20% ratio for you. Personal property is the exception: there you enter the assessed value from your county statement.
Taxable value
The assessed value actually used to calculate a real property tax bill, after Amendment 79's limitations on assessment increases are applied. This can legitimately be lower than the full assessed value. You can enter it in the calculator by choosing the taxable assessed value option.
| Assessor's field | Example amount |
|---|---|
| Estimated Market Value | $300,000 |
| Full Assessed (20% Market Value) | $60,000 |
| Taxable Value (illustrative; lower because of Amendment 79's cap on annual increases) | $52,000 |
These numbers can all legitimately be different for the same property; the taxable value shown is an invented figure to make that point. This calculator uses Estimated Market Value by default, or your taxable assessed value if you select that method — see "Which number should I enter?" above the property-value field.
Published worked examples (May 2, 2026 presentation)1
These are the study's original figures, shown for reference. They count the full 5 mills as a new tax, use the May fee estimates, and charge vacant lots the Recreation fee, so their totals are higher than the live calculator above. For a $300,000 home the difference is $240 a year in property tax the City already collects.
For reference, here are the exact worked examples from the original feasibility deck, using that presentation's original fee figures ($634.80 sheriff / $860.78 police per improved property — since refined to $632 / $888 in the July 2026 update used above).
With sheriff/deputy contract
| Line item | $20K vacant lot | $150K house | $300K house |
|---|---|---|---|
| HISID assessment goes away | -$513.60 | -$834.60 | -$834.60 |
| Recreation USD fee | +$187.85 | +$187.85 | +$187.85 |
| Public Safety USD fee | $0.00 | +$634.80 | +$634.80 |
| 5-mill property tax | +$20.00 | +$150.00 | +$300.00 |
| 5-mill personal property tax | $0.00 | +$20.00 | +$40.00 |
| New 2.5% sales tax (est.) | $0.00 | +$270.00 | +$270.00 |
| Net annual change | -$305.75 | +$428.05 | +$598.05 |
With a new police department
| Line item | $20K vacant lot | $150K house | $300K house |
|---|---|---|---|
| HISID assessment goes away | -$513.60 | -$834.60 | -$834.60 |
| Recreation USD fee | +$187.85 | +$187.85 | +$187.85 |
| Public Safety USD fee | $0.00 | +$860.78 | +$860.78 |
| 5-mill property tax | +$20.00 | +$150.00 | +$300.00 |
| 5-mill personal property tax | $0.00 | +$30.00 | +$40.00 |
| New 2.5% sales tax (est.) | $0.00 | +$270.00 | +$270.00 |
| Net annual change | -$305.75 | +$664.03 | +$824.03 |
Sources cited on this page
- Mayor Dan Kees, "Can the City Do It All?" — A Feasibility Study, presented May 2, 2026 (updated May 6, 2026). Earlier feasibility estimate, not an adopted figure. PDF posted by the City; also listed on the City's Services page. Link
- Mayor Dan Kees, "The Future Holiday Island — Session 2: Protecting Our Citizens," presented July 11, 2026 (revised July 13, 2026). Earlier feasibility estimate, not an adopted figure. Presented in a public forum. The City has not posted it online as of October 2026, so the link opens a copy of the presentation PDF hosted by this site. Link
- City of Holiday Island, "State of the City: Planning for Holiday Island's Future," January 2026. Link
- City of Holiday Island & Holiday Island Suburban Improvement District, Long Range Plan, September 22, 2026 (Resolution 2026-015). Link
- Arkansas Department of Finance and Administration, Assessment Coordination Division, 2025 Millage Report (2026 Collections), published March 2026 (Carroll County city millage breakdown). Link
- Arkansas Constitution, Article 12, § 4 (5-mill limit on municipal property tax). Link